6
Initially, a judge serves a two-year provisional term before standing for retention and then serves a full
term. A county judge serves a four-year term; a district judge, six years; a Court of Appeals judge, eight
years; and a Supreme Court justice, 10 years. All judges must retire by age 72.
Our courts also benet from the service of retired judges, who may be appointed at the request of
trial courts, to hear cases in which judges have recused themselves or to ll in when a judge is absent or
when there is a judicial vacancy or an overscheduled docket. Senior judges contract to provide 60 or 90
days of service per year. In return, the judge’s retirement benet is temporarily increased.
For more information on judicial nominating commissions, please click here.
JUDICIAL PERFORMANCE
In 1988, the Colorado General Assembly created judicial performance commissions for the purpose
of providing voters with fair, responsible, and constructive evaluations of trial and appellate judges and
justices. The evaluations enable voters to make informed decisions in judicial retention elections, and also
provide judges with information that can be used to improve their professional skills.
The State Commission on Judicial Performance develops evaluation techniques for district and
county judges, judges of the Court of Appeals, and justices of the Supreme Court. Criteria include
integrity; knowledge and understanding of substantive, procedural, and evidentiary law; communication
skills; preparation for, attentiveness to, and control over judicial proceedings; sentencing practices; docket
management and prompt case disposition; administrative skills; punctuality; effectiveness in working with
participants in the judicial process; and services to the legal profession and the public.
Each judicial district has its own 10-member Judicial Performance Commission. The governor and
chief justice each appoint one attorney and two non-attorneys. The president of the Senate and speaker
of the House each appoint one attorney and one non-attorney.
The state commission is responsible for evaluating the performance of judges of the Court of Appeals
and of the justices of the Supreme Court. Its members are appointed in a similar manner.
Narrative proles and recommendations concerning judicial retention are made available at least 45
days before each general election for those judges subject to that year’s retention vote. The information is
available on the Internet and is published in the Colorado Legislature’s Blue Book of Ballot Issues, which
is mailed to each voter household prior to the election.
For more information on the commissions, please click here.
COMMISSION ON JUDICIAL DISCIPLINE
The Colorado Commission on Judicial Discipline oversees the ethical conduct and behavior of state
court judges, justices, and senior judges. Created in 1966, the commission is composed of 10 members:
four citizens, two attorneys, two district court judges, and two county court judges. The citizen and
attorney members are appointed by the governor and must be approved by the Colorado Senate. The
judge members are appointed by the Colorado Supreme Court. Commission members serve staggered
four-year terms.
The commission does not have jurisdiction over Denver County Court or municipal court judges.
Complaints against these judges go to the mayors of the respective cities.
The commission has the constitutional authority to investigate allegations of any of the following acts:
• Willful misconduct by a judge, including misconduct which, although not related to judicial duties,
brings the judicial ofce into disrepute or is prejudicial to the administration of justice;
• Willful or persistent failure of a judge to perform judicial duties, including the incompetent
performance of judicial duties;
• Intemperance, including extreme or immoderate personal conduct, recurring loss of temper or control,
abuse of alcohol, or the use of illegal narcotics or dangerous drugs;
• Any conduct on the part of a judge that constitutes a violation of the Colorado Code of Judicial
Conduct; or
• A disability, which is or is likely to become permanent, that interferes with the performance of judicial
duties.
For more information on the commission, please click here.